Ian Gregor - Reading Mrs Gaskell's Life of Charlotte Brontë after Jane Eyre...

Reading Mrs Gaskell's Life of Charlotte Brontë after Jane Eyre is a curious experience. The subject of the biography is recognisably the same person who wrote the novel, but the effect of the two books is utterly different. The biography is indeed depressing and painful reading. It captures better, I believe, than any anysubsequent biography the introverted and puritan pessimist side of Charlotte Brontë, and conveys the real dreariness of the world of privation, critical discouragement and limited opportunity thatso often made her complain in her letters that she felt marked out for suffering. Jane Eyre, on the other hand, is exhilarating reading, partly because the reader, far from simply pitying the heroine, is struck by her resilience, and partly because the novel achieves such an imaginative transmutation of the drab. Unlike that of Jane Austen's Fanny Price or Dickens's Arthur Clennam or John Harmon, JaneEyre's response to suffering is never less than energetic. The reader is torn between exasperation at the way she mistakes her resentments and prejudices for fair moral judgements, and admiration at the way she fights back. Matthew Arnold, seeking 'sweetness and light' was repelled by the 'hunger, rebellion and rage' that heidentified as the keynotes of the novel. One can see why, and yet feel that these have a more positive effect than his phrase allows. The heroine is trying to hold on to her sense of self in a world that gives it little encouragement, and the novel does put up a persuasive case for her arrogance and pugnacity as the healthier alternativesto patience and resignation. That the book has created aworld in which the golden mean seems such a feeble solution is both its eccentricity and its strength.

Ian Gregor

;
Reading Mrs Gaskell's Life of Charlotte Brontë after Jane Eyre is a curious experience. The subject of the biography is recognisably the same person who wrote the novel, but the effect of the two books is utterly different. The biography is indeed depressing and painful reading. It captures better, I believe, than any anysubsequent biography the introverted and puritan pessimist side of Charlotte Brontë, and conveys the real dreariness of the world of privation, critical discouragement and limited opportunity thatso often made her complain in her letters that she felt marked out for suffering. Jane Eyre, on the other hand, is exhilarating reading, partly because the reader, far from simply pitying the heroine, is struck by her resilience, and partly because the novel achieves such an imaginative transmutation of the drab. Unlike that of Jane Austen's Fanny Price or Dickens's Arthur Clennam or John Harmon, JaneEyre's response to suffering is never less than energetic. The reader is torn between exasperation at the way she mistakes her resentments and prejudices for fair moral judgements, and admiration at the way she fights back. Matthew Arnold, seeking 'sweetness and light' was repelled by the 'hunger, rebellion and rage' that heidentified as the keynotes of the novel. One can see why, and yet feel that these have a more positive effect than his phrase allows. The heroine is trying to hold on to her sense of self in a world that gives it little encouragement, and the novel does put up a persuasive case for her arrogance and pugnacity as the healthier alternativesto patience and resignation. That the book has created aworld in which the golden mean seems such a feeble solution is both its eccentricity and its strength. Ian Gregor

Related Topics

Keywords

reading mrs gaskell' life charlotte brontã« jane eyre curious experience subject biography recognisably person wrote effect books utterly depressing painful captures anysubsequent introverted puritan pessimist side conveys real dreariness world privation critical discouragement limited opportunity thatso made complain letters felt marked suffering hand exhilarating partly reader simply pitying heroine struck resilience achieves imaginative transmutation drab unlike austen' fanny price dickens' arthur clennam john harmon janeeyre' response energetic torn exasperation mistakes resentments prejudices fair moral judgements admiration fights back matthew arnold seeking 'sweetness light' repelled 'hunger rebellion rage' heidentified keynotes feel positive phrase hold sense encouragement put persuasive case arrogance pugnacity healthier alternativesto patience resignation book created aworld golden feeble solution eccentricity strength

Explore other Authors


If you are using this quote in any webpage , printmedia or any other places please use the following methods to cite this quotation.

MLA Style Citation
"A quote by Ian Gregor" theysaidso.com, 2024. Mar 29, 2024. https://theysaidso.com/quote/ian-gregor-reading-mrs-gaskells-life-of-charlotte-bronte-after-jane-eyre-is-a-cu
APA Style Citation
"A quote by Ian Gregor" (n.d.). theysaidso.com. Retrieved Mar 29, 2024, from theysaidso.com web site : https://theysaidso.com/quote/ian-gregor-reading-mrs-gaskells-life-of-charlotte-bronte-after-jane-eyre-is-a-cu
Chicago Style Citation
"A quote by Ian Gregor". theysaidso.com, 2024. https://theysaidso.com/quote/ian-gregor-reading-mrs-gaskells-life-of-charlotte-bronte-after-jane-eyre-is-a-cu , accessed Mar 29, 2024.

Comments

Authentication required

You must log in to post a comment.

Log in

There are no comments yet.