Leo Tolstoy - [from ]For a historian considering the achievement of a certain...

[from ]For a historian considering the achievement of a certain aim, there are heroes; for the artist treating of a man's relation to all sides of life there cannot and should not be heroes, but there should be men.[..]The historian has to deal with the results of an event, the artist with the fact of the event. An historian in describing a battle says: 'The left flank of such and such an army was advanced to attack such and such a village and drove out the enemy, but was compelled to retire; then the cavalry, which was sent to attack, overthrew..' and so on. But these words have no meaning for the artist and do not actually touch on the event itself. Either from his own experience, or from the letters, memoirs, and accounts, the artist realizes a certain event to himself, and very often (to take the example of a battle) the deductions the historian permits himself to make as to the activity of such and such armies prove to be the very opposite of the artist's deductions. The difference of the results arrived at is also to be explained by the sources from which the two draw their information. For the historian (to keep to the case of a battle) the chief source is found in the reports of the commanding officers and the commander-in-chief. The artist can draw nothing from such sources; they tell him nothing and explain nothing to him. More than that: the artist turns away from them as he finds inevitable falsehood in them. To say nothing of the fact that after any battle the two sides nearly always describe it in quite contradictory ways, in every description of a battle there is a necessary lie, resulting from the need of describing in a few words the actions of thousands of men spread over several miles, and subject to most violent moral excitement under the influence of fear, shame and death.

Leo Tolstoy

;
[from ]For a historian considering the achievement of a certain aim, there are heroes; for the artist treating of a man's relation to all sides of life there cannot and should not be heroes, but there should be men.[..]The historian has to deal with the results of an event, the artist with the fact of the event. An historian in describing a battle says: 'The left flank of such and such an army was advanced to attack such and such a village and drove out the enemy, but was compelled to retire; then the cavalry, which was sent to attack, overthrew..' and so on. But these words have no meaning for the artist and do not actually touch on the event itself. Either from his own experience, or from the letters, memoirs, and accounts, the artist realizes a certain event to himself, and very often (to take the example of a battle) the deductions the historian permits himself to make as to the activity of such and such armies prove to be the very opposite of the artist's deductions. The difference of the results arrived at is also to be explained by the sources from which the two draw their information. For the historian (to keep to the case of a battle) the chief source is found in the reports of the commanding officers and the commander-in-chief. The artist can draw nothing from such sources; they tell him nothing and explain nothing to him. More than that: the artist turns away from them as he finds inevitable falsehood in them. To say nothing of the fact that after any battle the two sides nearly always describe it in quite contradictory ways, in every description of a battle there is a necessary lie, resulting from the need of describing in a few words the actions of thousands of men spread over several miles, and subject to most violent moral excitement under the influence of fear, shame and death. Leo Tolstoy

Related Topics

Keywords

[ ] historian achievement aim heroes artist treating man' relation sides life men deal results event fact describing battle ' left flank army advanced attack village drove enemy compelled retire cavalry overthrew words meaning touch experience letters memoirs accounts realizes deductions permits make activity armies prove opposite artist' difference arrived explained sources draw information case chief source found reports commanding officers commander- -chief explain turns finds inevitable falsehood describe contradictory ways description lie resulting actions thousands spread miles subject violent moral excitement influence fear shame death

Explore other Authors


If you are using this quote in any webpage , printmedia or any other places please use the following methods to cite this quotation.

MLA Style Citation
"A quote by Leo Tolstoy" theysaidso.com, 2024. Apr 20, 2024. https://theysaidso.com/quote/leo-tolstoy-from-for-a-historian-considering-the-achievement-of-a-certain-aim-th
APA Style Citation
"A quote by Leo Tolstoy" (n.d.). theysaidso.com. Retrieved Apr 20, 2024, from theysaidso.com web site : https://theysaidso.com/quote/leo-tolstoy-from-for-a-historian-considering-the-achievement-of-a-certain-aim-th
Chicago Style Citation
"A quote by Leo Tolstoy". theysaidso.com, 2024. https://theysaidso.com/quote/leo-tolstoy-from-for-a-historian-considering-the-achievement-of-a-certain-aim-th , accessed Apr 20, 2024.

Comments

Authentication required

You must log in to post a comment.

Log in

There are no comments yet.